Fanatec CSL Pedals vs Simagic P500 Pedal

The CSL Pedals costs $9.01 less than the P500 Pedal.

FanatecCSL Pedals
Fanatec CSL Pedals
Image: Fanatec
$139.99checked 2026-09-13PCPlayStation 5Xbox Series X|S
SimagicP500 Pedal
Simagic P500 Pedal
Image: Simagic
$149checked 2026-09-13

What separates them

1Differ
2One side only
0Identical
2Neither publishes
  • Price$139.99vs$149

    The CSL Pedals costs $9.01 less than the P500 Pedal.

Specs side by side

Fanatec CSL PedalsSimagic P500 Pedal
Where they differ
Price$139.99$149
Published by one side
Pedals3Not published
PlatformsPC, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|SNot published
Not published by eitherbrake type · load cell rating

Fanatec CSL Pedals: pros, cons, and who it suits

Pros

  • Costs $9.01 less than the P500 Pedal.
  • Works on PC, which the P500 Pedal does not list support for.
  • Works on PlayStation 5, which the P500 Pedal does not list support for.
  • Works on Xbox Series X|S, which the P500 Pedal does not list support for.

Cons

Nothing in the published specs counts against it here.

Who it suits

Sits in the under $300 band at $139.99.

Simagic P500 Pedal: pros, cons, and who it suits

Pros

Nothing in the published specs favours it over the CSL Pedals.

Cons

  • Costs $9.01 more than the CSL Pedals.
  • No published PC support, where the CSL Pedals lists it.
  • No published PlayStation 5 support, where the CSL Pedals lists it.
  • No published Xbox Series X|S support, where the CSL Pedals lists it.

Who it suits

Sits in the under $300 band at $149.

Which should you choose?

On budget alone, the CSL Pedals is the cheaper of the two at $139.99, against $149 for the P500 Pedal.

If you are on PC, only the CSL Pedals publishes support for it.

If you are on PlayStation 5, only the CSL Pedals publishes support for it.

If you are on Xbox Series X|S, only the CSL Pedals publishes support for it.

Where to buy

Fanatec

CSL Pedals

$139.99

Check price at Fanatec
vs
Simagic

P500 Pedal

$149

Check price at Simagic

Full CSL Pedals specs · Full P500 Pedal specs

Sources

Every spec on this page was read from the manufacturer's own published documentation.